Cart is empty Close mini cart

Your cart is empty

Browse our services

Pros and Cons of a Surprise Engagement Ring Proposal

Written by Anna Currell
August 23, 2023

The thrill of a surprise engagement is undeniable — the anticipation, the involvement of friends and family, and the meticulous planning can all contribute to the excitement of the big moment. However, surprises may not be everyone's cup of tea, especially when it comes to proposals and engagement rings. As traditions evolve, the conventional approach of surprising your partner with a ring you've chosen might not be the ideal choice for every couple. In this article, we’ll delve into the pros and cons of surprise engagement ring proposals, and we’ll offer some valuable advice on how to create the perfect proposal experience.

Pros of a Surprise Engagement Ring Proposal

The long-observed tradition of surprising your partner with a ring you’ve chosen can be rewarding and fun. Let’s take a look at some of the reasons why surprise proposals are a great idea: 

  1. Element of surprise: If your partner gets a thrill from unexpected moments and gestures they never saw coming, a surprise proposal can create a memorable and magical experience for both of you. 
  2. Romantic gesture: Presenting your partner with an engagement ring out of the blue can be a deeply romantic gesture. It shows your thoughtfulness and commitment to the relationship, not to mention your willingness to put your heart on the line for your person.
  3. Less pressure on decision making for your partner: When you surprise your partner with a ring, you take the burden of choosing the perfect ring off their shoulders. Some people find it challenging to make such a significant decision, and a surprise proposal eliminates that stress. 
  4. Unforgettable story: A surprise proposal can create a great story that you and your partner can share with family and friends for years. It adds an extra layer of excitement and spontaneity to your relationship's narrative and makes a lovely memory to look back on. 


Cons of a Surprise Engagement Ring Proposal

On the other hand, surprises can sometimes backfire. Here are some of the downsides of catching your partner off guard with a surprise engagement ring: 

  1. Misaligned expectations: One of the biggest drawbacks of a surprise proposal is the potential for misaligned expectations. Your partner might have envisioned a totally different style or type of ring, and if it doesn't match their preferences, they could be disappointed. 
  2. Size and fit concerns: Surprise proposals often leave room for uncertainty when it comes to the ring size and fit. It can be challenging to accurately determine your partner's ring size without their input, which may lead to resizing or alterations after the proposal.
  3. Involvement in decision making: Some people prefer to be actively involved in the decision making process of choosing an engagement ring. It can be a really fun thing to shop for! By surprising them with a ring, you might inadvertently exclude them from an important decision and the opportunity to enjoy this fun activity together.
  4. Financial considerations: Surprise engagement ring proposals could lead to financial concerns. If your partner had a different budget in mind or if you splurged on a ring they might not have chosen themselves, it could cause stress or strain on your finances — especially if you’re going to be planning an expensive wedding after they say “yes.” 

Advice for Planning a Surprise Engagement Ring Proposal

Now that you have a good idea about the pros and cons of a surprise engagement ring proposal, you can make an informed decision about planning a proposal in the best way for you and your partner. If you’re excited about making it a surprise, here’s some guidance about how to make sure it goes well:

Do Your Homework

If you decide to go ahead with a surprise proposal, make sure to gather as much information as possible about your partner's preferences beforehand. Pay attention to their style, favorite jewelry pieces, and any hints they may have dropped in conversations. Take a look at some of their current rings to get a good idea of the right size to choose and the type of metal they might prefer. 

Involve Close Friends or Family

Consider involving close friends or family members who can discreetly gather information about your partner's ring preferences. They can offer valuable insight and ensure that the ring aligns with their taste — your partner might have already confided in their friend, sibling, or parent about the exact ring they would want. 

Consider a Placeholder Ring

If you're concerned about choosing the perfect ring, or think that your partner will want a say in their ring, you can opt for a symbolic, temporary placeholder ring and plan to shop for the final ring together after the proposal. This way, you can still surprise your partner while allowing them to actively participate in the ring selection process.

Communication is Key

Regardless of whether you plan a surprise proposal or involve your partner in the decision making, open and honest communication is essential. Discuss your expectations, preferences, and desires with each other to ensure a smooth and joyful proposal experience. Make sure you’re on the same page about the important things — like if this should be a public or private proposal, if your families should be there to celebrate or if you’d rather savor the time on your own as a newly engaged couple, and so on. 


While a surprise engagement ring proposal can be incredibly romantic and create unforgettable memories, it may not suit every couple's preferences. Remember, the most important aspect of any proposal is the love and commitment you share with your partner, regardless of the element of surprise. In the journey of planning your proposal, consider designing a custom engagement ring with Quick Jewelry Repairs. By crafting a unique and personalized ring, you can make sure it perfectly reflects your partner's style and preferences. Our team of skilled jewelers will work closely with you to bring your vision to life, creating a truly one-of-a-kind symbol of your love that your partner will cherish.

Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments